Anxiety in pregnancy is common and often untreated: two trials test what online help can do

Almost a quarter of women report anxiety symptoms by the third trimester, yet many go untreated. A self-led online programme cut anxiety in a UK trial, while an AI chatbot tested in the US made no measurable difference.

6 min read

Almost a quarter of women report anxiety symptoms by the third trimester, yet many go untreated. A self-led online programme cut anxiety in a UK trial, while an AI chatbot tested in the US made no measurable difference.

Content note: this article mentions maternal deaths by suicide. Support details are at the end.

How common is anxiety in pregnancy?

Anxiety symptoms affect 18.2% of women in the first trimester and 24.6% in the third, a global review found. Fewer women meet the criteria for a diagnosed anxiety disorder. Symptoms were more common in low- and middle-income countries than in high-income ones.

Almost one in five women will have a mental health condition in pregnancy or the year after birth, the World Health Organization (WHO) estimates.

Why do women become anxious in pregnancy?

The UK charity Tommy's explains that the brain changes during pregnancy to prepare for parenthood. Uncertainty about the future and the wish to protect the baby can add to that worry. Anxiety becomes a health problem when it disrupts daily life and is hard to control.

Most women with an anxiety disorder in a UK diagnostic interview study had a past mental health problem. Tommy's also lists a family history of anxiety or depression, trauma or abuse, and long-term or painful conditions. Stress from relationship problems, money worries or job loss raises the risk too.

Extreme fear of childbirth, known as tokophobia, affects between 5% and 14% of women.

Has pregnancy anxiety increased?

COVID-19 pushed reported rates up, with a rapid review of studies during the pandemic finding anxiety in 30.5% of pregnant women. The UK interview study, carried out in 2021 and 2022, found rates in line with earlier research. Surveys use different scales and thresholds, so no large dataset yet shows a clear trend since the pandemic.

What does anxiety mean for mother and baby?

Anxiety in pregnancy is linked to higher odds of preterm birth and low birth weight. The studies behind that finding were observational, so they cannot prove that anxiety causes these outcomes.

In the UK and Ireland, mental health problems were the leading cause of maternal death between six weeks and one year after pregnancy. The period covered was 2021 to 2023, and the causes included suicide and substance use. The finding comes from the MBRRACE-UK confidential enquiry. For many of the women who died by suicide, assessors judged that different care might have changed the outcome.

Few women with a diagnosed anxiety or depressive disorder were receiving treatment in the UK interview study, and most said they did not want it. The authors called for care built on relationships, which explores each woman's preferences and barriers.

What the RELAX trial found

Researchers at King's College London developed RELAX, a self-led online programme. It trains people to read ambiguous situations in a less threatening way, a technique called cognitive bias modification for interpretation. Women completed 12 short sessions over four weeks, alongside usual maternity care.

The trial, published in JAMA Network Open on 4 November, included 268 pregnant women recruited through NHS antenatal clinics and self-referral. All had high levels of repetitive negative thinking, a known risk factor for anxiety.

Women who used RELAX had lower anxiety scores after eight weeks than those who received usual care alone. The benefit was smaller but still there months after birth, and scores for postnatal depression were also lower.

Both effects are modest. The trial excluded women with high anxiety, and most participants were White British and highly educated. A larger trial in a more varied population would show whether the benefit holds.

What the AI chatbot trial found

University of Maryland researchers tested a very different tool in a second trial in the same journal. They gave 400 pregnant women and new mothers access to Rosie, a generative AI chatbot that answers maternal health questions. All came from racial and ethnic minority groups across the US. A comparison group received monthly children's books.

After 12 months, the chatbot made no difference to anxiety or depression. It also made no difference to emergency department visits, postnatal check-ups, contraception use or sleep. Among women who were pregnant when they joined, complications were higher in the chatbot group after statistical adjustment. The authors treat that as a signal for further research.

The authors suggest that a chatbot may work better as an addition to care than as a standalone service. Read together, the two trials suggest that a structured programme aimed at one known risk factor can reduce anxiety. Open-ended information on demand has yet to show the same benefit.

Which treatments have good evidence?

Talking therapies reduce anxiety in pregnancy and after birth, a 2022 review in Psychology and Psychotherapy found. Results were strongest for cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) and mindfulness-based approaches.

England's National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) sets out a stepped approach in its antenatal and postnatal mental health guideline. Midwives and GPs should consider asking two short questions about anxiety at the first appointment and early after birth. Women with milder symptoms can be offered supported self-help based on CBT, and those with an anxiety disorder can be offered CBT itself.

Fear of childbirth responds to help too. A 2021 review in Psychological Medicine found that most approaches reduced it, from talking therapies to antenatal education and extra midwife support.

The NHS advises women already taking medicine for anxiety to speak to their doctor promptly. The doctor may suggest continuing it, switching, or combining it with CBT. Tommy's advises women not to stop medication before talking to their doctor.

WHO's 2022 guide asks countries to build mental health care into routine maternity and child health services. It calls for health workers to be trained to recognise symptoms and respond in ways that suit local cultures. Trained frontline staff are most needed where specialist services are scarce, including many low- and middle-income countries.

Where women can find help and information

Midwives, GPs and obstetricians are the first point of contact. The NHS says doctors and midwives are used to treating anxiety in pregnancy, and women will not be judged for asking for help. Any woman who feels anxious all the time should raise it at her next appointment or sooner.

In the UK, the NHS guide to anxiety in pregnancy covers symptoms, self-help and treatment. The NHS also lists mental health services for pregnancy and after birth. Tommy's has a Wellbeing Plan to help women talk to their partner, family or midwife.

Postpartum Support International supports women from pregnancy onwards and has support coordinators in 65 countries. Its US helpline is 800-944-4773, by call or text.

If you are struggling or having thoughts of harming yourself, contact your doctor, midwife or local emergency number now. Postpartum Support International can also help you find local support in many countries.

This content is for information only and does not replace advice from a qualified health professional.

Header image: Photo by Suhyeon Choi on Unsplash

Get the week's essential women's health journalism

Evidence-based reporting, delivered to your inbox every week. No hype, no fads.